Filed under: Uncategorized
The site Who Killed William Robinson certain is an interesting way of looking at history. By tweeking the users interests with mystery and an opportunity to weigh in on the outcome could help a variety of historical subjects that students might initially consider borring. In the case of William Robinson’s death there is a lot of information provided by the site, so much so it is hard to know where to start. But that is part of the beauty of this type of digital history. Each person will see the evidence differently because likely each user will find their own path through the infomation. Even if everyone started on the same page they would more than likely choose differently the next time, or the time after that. Suppositions and theories will be developed early on. Because it would be very difficult a time consuming to view every peiece of evidence the user will like try to find sources that would strengthen their original hypothesis. On the other hand they could find something that dashes their idea to pieces.
It was interesting viewing the undergrad blogs because many had some very different and original ideas. I particularly like they theory of the judge being the murderer. Most were not as silly as this and had some real thought put into it. Even if the real answer could never be found it would appear that this is a valuable history teaching tool.
After reading some of the evidence and the undergrad blogs I would have to agree that Tom probably got a raw deal in this trial. Considering the strong likelihood of discrimination towards native indians fairness was rarely in play. But no matter how one slices it the testimony by young Dick is extremely damaging. The big question is why might Dick have testified against his friend if he did not do it? Because of the time differential their could be any number of reasons; coersion, revenge, etc. The prosecution was likely more than happy to execute the accused to maintain the appearance of justice and peace in small community. I question the use of the axe handle as evidence against Tom as there is far too much speculation and issues of memory. I would be much more interested to know the whereabouts of Robinson’s gun.
Leave a Comment so far
Leave a comment
